Report: Yankees Re-Sign Paul Blackburn – Unexpected Return

The Yankees’ rotation is hanging by a thread with injuries piling up, but Brian Cashman just made a sneaky move that could keep the season from falling apart.

The Bronx Bombers officially brought back right-hander Paul Blackburn on a one-year, $2 million deal. If that name sounds familiar, it’s because the 32-year-old veteran was quietly excellent for the Yankees down the stretch last season after the Mets cut him loose in August.

The Deal Everyone’s Talking About

Blackburn’s contract includes performance bonuses of $100,000 each for reaching 80, 90, 100, 110, and 120 innings pitched, which could push the total value to $2.5 million. That’s basically pocket change in today’s baseball economy, but the incentives tell you everything about how the Yankees plan to use him.

This isn’t just a bullpen arm. The innings thresholds suggest Blackburn could get spot starts or handle multiple-inning relief appearances — exactly what New York desperately needs right now.

Read more: Jake Bird Yankees Stats, Age, Wife, Salary, Height, Weight, Contract

Why This Matters More Than You Think

Here’s the harsh reality facing the Yankees: Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodón, and Clarke Schmidt are all dealing with injuries that could sideline them to start the season. That leaves Max Fried as the only guaranteed ace at the top of the rotation.

Suddenly, Blackburn’s ability to swing between starting and long relief becomes incredibly valuable. He’s done it his entire career, and while his numbers don’t exactly scream “All-Star,” he brings something money can’t always buy: experience and versatility.

Blackburn — a 2022 All-Star who spent most of his MLB career with Oakland — had a rough 2025 overall (a 6.23 ERA over 39.0 innings), and specifically posted a 6.85 ERA in 23.2 innings for the Mets before being released and picked up by New York.

But here’s what the stats don’t show: Blackburn figured something out in pinstripes. After a brutal debut where he got shelled, he locked in and became a different pitcher. Over his final 12 innings in a Yankees uniform, he gave up just two earned runs for a sparkling 1.50 ERA. That late-season surge is exactly why they’re bringing him back.

What the Front Office Sees

General managers love guys like Blackburn. He’s not going to blow anyone away with 98 mph fastballs or ridiculous strikeout numbers. What he does is eat innings, keep his team in games, and provide stability when younger arms falter or injuries strike.

At 32 he has plenty of big-league experience — Blackburn has pitched in the majors primarily for the Oakland A’s, and in 2024–25 he was with the Mets before joining the Yankees; earlier in his career he also spent time in the Mariners’ organization in the minors.

The Yankees ranked 23rd in MLB bullpen performance last year, so adding reliable arms who can bridge games or step into emergency starts isn’t just smart — it’s essential.

The Bigger Picture

This signing fits perfectly into New York’s offseason strategy of building depth without breaking the bank. They’ve also brought back Ryan Yarbrough on a similar deal and exercised Tim Hill’s option. None of these moves will make headlines or win fantasy leagues, but they’re the kind of chess moves that keep contenders afloat during the marathon that is a 162-game season.

With the Yankees projected as one of the favorites to contend in 2026, having veteran insurance like Blackburn could be the difference between scrambling for Triple-A call-ups in May or maintaining steady production while waiting for stars to return.

What Happens Next

All eyes will be on Blackburn during spring training in Tampa. Can he replicate that late-season magic from 2025? Does he crack the rotation or settle into a high-leverage bullpen role? Manager Aaron Boone will have options, which is exactly what you want heading into a long season.

The Yankees don’t need Blackburn to be a hero. They just need him to be reliable, professional, and ready when his number’s called. For $2 million, that’s a bet worth making every single time.

And if those rotation injuries linger longer than expected? This “minor” signing could end up being one of the smartest moves Cashman makes all winter.