Yankees Acquire Ryan Weathers in Surprise Trade

The Yankees are facing a rotation crisis that could derail their entire 2026 campaign. But their latest trade with the Marlins might be the perfect solution—if Ryan Weathers can stay healthy.

Why This Trade Is Bigger Than You Think

New York just acquired 26-year-old lefty Ryan Weathers from Miami, sending four prospects south: outfielders Dillon Lewis and Brendan Jones, plus infielders Dylan Jasso and Juan Matheus. On paper, it looks like a standard depth move. The trade is consistent with a team adding controllable pitching depth amid offseason rotation uncertainty.

Here’s the situation: Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón will both start the season on the injured list, recovering from elbow surgeries. Clarke Schmidt might miss the entire year after Tommy John surgery last July. That leaves Max Fried and a bunch of question marks to carry the rotation early in the season.

The Gamble on Weathers

Weathers brings serious upside to the Bronx. His fastball now sits at 96-97 mph—way up from his earlier career—and he’s developed a nasty changeup and sweeper that can miss bats. When healthy, scouts see a legitimate mid-rotation arm who can eat innings and give you a chance to win.

The problem? That “when healthy” part is doing a lot of heavy lifting.

Weathers made just eight starts in 2025. Eight. He missed three months early in the season with a flexor strain, then came back for five solid starts before a lat strain shut him down until September. In 2024, a finger injury limited him to 16 starts. Over the past two seasons, he’s thrown only 125 innings.

But here’s what the Yankees are betting on: those injury-shortened stretches showed flashes of brilliance. Weathers posted a 3.99 ERA last season with a sub-1.30 WHIP. His strikeout rate is solid at 22%, and his walk rate stays low. The stuff is legit.

Read more: Jake Bird Yankees Stats, Age, Wife, Salary, Height, Weight, Contract

What Miami Gets (And Why They Did This)

The Marlins aren’t tanking—they’re just playing 4D chess with their roster. After trading Edward Cabrera to the Cubs last week, dealing Weathers makes room for their top pitching prospects, Thomas White and Robby Snelling, to crack the big league rotation.

White is routinely listed among the top left-handed prospects and often inside various outlets’ Top-40 overall, while Robby Snelling also ranks inside many outlets’ Top-100 and among the top LHPs in baseball.

Dillon Lewis swatted 22 homers and stole 26 bases across lower levels in 2025 and has a reputation as an above-average raw-power hitter in scouting reports; some outlets compared his elite batted-ball metrics to other high-velocity hitters, but precise 90th-percentile Statcast exit-velocity figures for minor-leaguers are reported inconsistently across sources.

The Yankees’ Rotation Math

With Weathers now in pinstripes, the Opening Day rotation looks something like this: Max Fried at the top, followed by some combination of Weathers, Will Warren, Luis Gil, and Cam Schlittler. It’s a group with serious upside but also massive injury risk.

The good news? Weathers comes cheap. His $1.35 million salary barely moves the luxury tax needle for New York. Plus, he still has a minor league option remaining, giving the Yankees flexibility once Cole and Rodón return.

There’s also a fun storyline here: Weathers is the son of David Weathers, who pitched for the Yankees back in 1996. Now Ryan gets his shot in the same uniform.

Why This Could Work (Or Fail)

The Yankees aren’t done making moves. They’re still hunting for another starter and trying to lock down Cody Bellinger for the outfield. But Weathers represents something important: a team willing to take calculated risks on talented players with injury red flags.

If Weathers stays healthy and throws 25-30 starts, this trade looks like a steal. He slots in as a reliable third or fourth starter who can bridge the gap until the veterans return. His mid-90s heat and improved breaking stuff should play well in the American League East.

If he breaks down again? The Yankees gave up four prospects for basically nothing, and their rotation depth takes another hit when they can least afford it.

The Bottom Line

This trade reveals everything about where both teams stand right now. The Yankees are in win-now mode and need bodies to survive the first half of the season. The Marlins are building for the future and cashing in on controllable pitchers before injuries tank their trade value completely.

Weathers is under team control through 2028, giving New York three full seasons to figure out if the talent matches the potential. At just $1.35 million, it’s not going to break the bank. But in a division as brutal as the AL East, every rotation spot matters.

The clock starts now for Ryan Weathers to prove he can be the guy the Yankees desperately need him to be.